A review needs to be of a very high quality and conform to a standardised format to maintain and improve the already exacting standards of JEO. We ask you to adhere to the stringent standards (set out below ) as it is the most useful feedback we can give to our authors. Therefore, we ask you to pay meticulous attention to every part of the manuscript.
Confidential Comments to the Editor should include:
- General comment about the manuscript
- Originality of idea
- Scientific content
- Length of the manuscript
- Recommendation as to whether it should be accepted, revised or rejected.
Comments to the Author should include: