Reviewers Homepage

Dear Reviewers,

A review needs to be of a very high quality and conform to a standardised format to maintain and improve the already exacting standards of JEO. We ask you to adhere to the stringent standards (set out below ) as it is the most useful feedback we can give to our authors. Therefore, we ask you to pay meticulous attention to every part of the manuscript.

Example of a good JEO review

Confidential Comments to the Editor should include:

  • General comment about the manuscript
  • Originality of idea
  • Scientific content
  • Length of the manuscript
  • Recommendation as to whether it should be accepted, revised or rejected.

Comments to the Author should include:

General Comments
Abstract
Levels of evidence
Title
Introduction
Methods and Materials
Results
Discussion
Conclusion
References
Figures
Tables